By Stuart Love
Friday Legal
WHAT do you do if a third party interferes with your legally binding contract causing the other party to withdraw? Parties to contracts can be put under commercial pressure not to perform their obligation for all sorts of reasons, but, as Lucasfilm (the owners of the intellectual property in the Star Wars franchise) found out to their cost, there is a remedy!
What happened?
The High Court has recently decided that attempts made by Lucasfilm to prevent the filming and live cinema broadcast of an unofficial Star Wars convention in Manchester in December 2015 amounted to a wrongful inducement of a third party to breach its contract.
The claimant, Marc John, was an independent film producer and distributor who had struck a deal with the organisers of the convention to film it and broadcast live to cinemas.
The convention was due to take place shortly before the release of Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens. In August 2015, lawyers for Lucasfilm sent the convention organisers a series of ultimatums alleging breach of copyright and trademark infringement, which they would action in the event that the convention organiser did not undertake to prevent the filming and cinema broadcast going ahead.
Ultimately, Lucasfilm achieved its initial commercial objective, the convention organiser complied with its demands and the filming and broadcast did not go ahead.
Mr John, however, was convinced he had been wronged and a result had suffered a real financial loss.
The Case
He claimed that Lucasfilm had wrongfully induced the convention organiser to breach its contract with him. Lucasfilm defended the claim on the basis that: –
* There was an implied term in the contract between Mr John and the convention organiser that Lucasfilm’s permission had to be obtained for the film; and
* That Mr John and the convention organiser had agreed for their agreement to be rescinded.
The Outcome
The Court did not accept Lucasfilm’s arguments and found in favour of Mr John.
In finding for Mr. John it decided that Lucasfilm had the requisite knowledge and intention to induce a breach of contract.
In summary, if a party has ‘blind eye knowledge’ or is reckless as to whether its conduct would induce a breach that is sufficient to constitute unlawful interference with contract.
However, it did not all go Mr John’s way, he had argued that as a consequence of Lucasfilm’s actions he had incurred a loss of £1.34 million, while the court did agree that it was likely he would have made a profit from the venture it assessed his likely losses more modestly and awarded him the sum of £39,504.
If you have found yourself in the same position as Mr John or have experienced any other problems with contracts not being performed, contact the Dispute Resolution team at Friday Legal Solicitors to discuss your options.
Further details in relation to the excellent commercial, corporate, commercial property, employment and Dispute Resolution services offered by Friday Legal Solicitors can be found on the website at www.fridaylegal.com or via telephone on 01536 218888. Alternatively, you can contact the Head of the Dispute Resolution team, Stuart Love, directly by email to [email protected]

