By Phil Harris
Principal
Harris & Co
THERE has been a mixed response to the recently published review of workplace practices that advocates an improved national strategy for work.
The various responses to the Taylor Review of Modern Working Practices was entirely predictable – The Federation for Small Businesses cautiously welcomed the review, while the CBI focused on the need to maintain a flexible labour market.
It came as no surprise, of course, to hear that the TUC are disappointed with the review, claiming that it is a missed opportunity and should have gone much further with its key recommendations.
In his summary, author Matthew Taylor said that the review had its basis in the fact that all work in the UK economy should be ‘fair and decent with realistic scope for development and fulfillment’. He added that despite the important contribution of the living wage and benefits, all work should offer routes to progress, even to those on lower incomes, and that everyone should be treated with respect and decency at work.
A brief summary of the seven recommendations of the review is as follows:
1. A new national strategy for work, recognising that good work should be available for all
2. Platform (APP) based workers should be protected with clearer employment definitions
3. Dependent contractors need greater legislative protection
4. Good working practices needs to be encouraged for all employers
5. Work prospects need improving
6. Workplace health needs greater consideration
7. People must not get “stuck” on the national living wage
The review leant heavily in favour of the perceived imbalance between the engager and the worker. It also seemed to hark back to the days when everyone worked down at the mill, nine to five, five days a week. That type of economy disappeared in the 1950s!
The review, however, did not address some key aspects of the modern economy:
* Workers have the freedom to decide where and when to work. The Government should not be responsible for removing these freedoms
* The Labour market in the 21st century must retain its flexibility if we are to be competitive internationally
* Self employment should be for the individual to decide, not the Government
The fact is that, as things stand, neither the employer nor the employee decides whether the worker is self-employed, rather it is a factual assessment of the nature of their employment. This is becoming increasingly important due to the nature of some self-employed roles.
Self-employment reached a high of 15 per cent of total employment during 2016, and the trend towards self-employment has been particularly rapid since the recession.
The question of who is self-employed and who is not is becoming blurred, with many working practices meaning that the rules designed many years ago simply do not give us clear decisions about whether someone is self employed or not.
There will undoubtedly be many changes to the world of self-employment ahead!
For more information, contact Harris & Co on 01604 660661 or visit www.harrisandco.biz

